Child support shortfall: sharing too little money between several children
In a child support shortfall, income cannot cover every child’s minimum and the parent’s own floor, so all children are cut back in the same proportion.
Checked by Radif Partners · Editorial policy · Calculation method
Shortfall case with two children
Amount shared out
€450
| Child aged 4 | €204.36 |
| Child aged 10 | €245.64 |
| No shortfall from | €2,240 |
A shortfall case (Mangelfall) arises when the paying parent’s adjusted net income cannot cover both the parent’s minimum self-retention (Selbstbehalt) and the support of all children of equal rank. Under note C of the 2026 Düsseldorf Table, only the distributable amount (Verteilungsmasse) is then shared out: income minus the self-retention of €1,450 for a working parent or €1,200 for one who is not working. Each child receives the share that its own input amount (Einsatzbetrag), meaning its payable amount after child benefit, bears to the total. In the table’s official example, the father earns €1,750 and three children aged 18 (still at school), 7 and 5 would be owed €1,224.00 together. Only €300.00 is available, giving €107.60, €105.02 and €87.38. The full minimum would need about €2,680 net. Minors and adult school pupils rank first under section 1609 of the Civil Code (BGB), ahead of any spouse.
When German law speaks of a child support shortfall
The NRW court guidelines call it an absolute shortfall when the parent’s income cannot cover the minimum self-retention plus the equal-ranking claims of the children. The yardstick is the statutory minimum, which is group 1 of the table, after the child benefit share. Earn less than the self-retention plus those amounts, and you are in a shortfall case.
Before this point the table has usually stepped the income group down already: the needs-control amount lowers the group until there is no lower group left. Note C only starts once even group 1 cannot be afforded.
Note C in three steps
- Distributable amount: adjusted net income minus self-retention (€1,450 working, €1,200 not working).
- Input amounts: for each child, the group 1 amount minus child benefit (Kindergeld): half of €259 for minors, all of it for adult children.
- Sharing: each child gets its input amount times the distributable amount, divided by the total of input amounts.
The official example, recalculated
The Düsseldorf Table works through its own case: a father on €1,750 adjusted net income, three children living with their mother, who receives the child benefit. K1 is 18 and still at a general school, K2 is 7 and K3 is 5. The engine behind this site lands on the same cents.
| Child | Need, group 1 | Child benefit share | Input amount | Support in shortfall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| K1, aged 18 | €698 | €259.00 | €439.00 | €107.60 |
| K2, aged 7 | €558 | €129.50 | €428.50 | €105.02 |
| K3, aged 5 | €486 | €129.50 | €356.50 | €87.38 |
| Total | €1,224.00 | €300.00 |
Each child receives just under a quarter of its payable table amount. If the father could not work, for example through illness, his floor would be €1,200 and €550.00 would be shared: €197.27, €192.54 and €160.19. The lower floor only applies where work cannot be expected of him.
How the figures move with income
| Adjusted net | Shared out | K1 (18) | K2 (7) | K3 (5) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| €1,500 | €50.00 | €17.94 | €17.50 | €14.56 |
| €2,000 | €550.00 | €197.27 | €192.54 | €160.19 |
| €2,300 | €850.00 | €304.86 | €297.57 | €247.57 |
| €2,680 | full minimum | €439.00 | €428.50 | €356.50 |
Every euro above the self-retention goes to the children until all three minimums are met. That is why, in a shortfall, each deduction in the adjusted net income matters so much: commuting costs or loan repayments that the court accepts reduce the amount for the children one for one.
Ranking under section 1609 BGB
When other people are also entitled, the ranking in section 1609 BGB decides:
- Rank 1: minor children and adult pupils under 21 at a general school who live with a parent.
- Rank 2: a parent entitled to support for looking after a child, and spouses after a long marriage.
- Rank 3: other spouses and former spouses.
- Rank 4: other children, such as university students.
- Ranks 5 to 7: grandchildren, parents, then further ancestors.
A lower rank receives nothing until every higher rank is paid in full. Note C sharing only happens inside one rank.
The heightened duty to earn
Under section 1603(2) BGB, parents of minors must use all available means evenly for themselves and the children. Courts read this as a heightened duty to work: full time, if need be a change of job or town, overtime or a side job where reasonable. The NRW guidelines attribute income that could realistically be earned. For expats this can include whether a job in Germany at a comparable level was realistically available.
State top-up: the maintenance advance
For children under 18, the caring parent can apply for a maintenance advance. It equals the statutory minimum minus the full child benefit, less payments by the other parent under section 2 of the Maintenance Advance Act. For the seven-year-old above that leaves €193.98 a month if the other conditions are met. The state later reclaims it from the paying parent as far as he can pay.
The calculation follows note C of the 2026 Düsseldorf Table. This page is general information on how a shortfall is shared, not legal advice; the youth welfare office offers free support for children’s claims (Beistandschaft).