The gift top-up claim: when the estate was given away in advance
Giving assets away before death does not simply defeat a German compulsory share. The gift top-up claim adds the gift back to the estate, a little less each year.
Checked by Radif Partners · Editorial policy · Calculation method
How much of a gift still counts?
Top-up claim
€18,000
| Counted | 60 % = €72,000 |
If the deceased gave something away to a third party during their lifetime, a person entitled to a compulsory share in Germany can claim a top-up (Pflichtteilsergänzung) under section 2325 of the Civil Code (BGB): the amount by which their compulsory share would rise if the gift were still part of the estate. A gift counts in full within the first year before death and 10 % less for every further year; once 10 years have passed since it was performed, it is ignored. Suppose a widowed father of two gives his new partner €240,000 and dies four full years later: 60 % still counts, which is €144,000. A disinherited child with a compulsory fraction of 1/4 receives €36,000 from it, on top of the compulsory share out of the estate itself. Gifts to a spouse are not reduced: the period does not start before the marriage ends, so for a marriage lasting until death the gift counts in full. Where the donor keeps the use of the asset, for example through a usufruct (Nießbrauch), courts often treat the gift as not yet performed.
Why the gift top-up claim exists
A compulsory share is calculated from what is left on the day of death. Without a correction, anyone could hollow out their children’s rights by giving away the house, the portfolio or the company beforehand. Section 2325 BGB therefore treats the gift as if it were still in the estate and awards the claimant the difference. The claim belongs to anyone entitled under section 2303 BGB, even if they inherited half their statutory share as heir (section 2326 BGB).
The sliding scale
Section 2325(3) BGB counts a gift in full within the first year before death and 10 % less in each further year. After 10 years from performance the gift no longer counts. German lawyers call this the pro rata rule: the closer the gift was to death, the more of it counts.
The example: a widowed father with two children gives his new partner €240,000 and names her sole heir in his will. At his death €180,000 remains. Each child would have inherited 1/2 by law, so each compulsory share is 1/4 of the estate, €45,000. The top-up comes on top, depending on how long ago the gift was made:
| Full years since the gift | Counted | Value counted | Top-up per child |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 100 % | €240,000 | €60,000 |
| 1 | 90 % | €216,000 | €54,000 |
| 3 | 70 % | €168,000 | €42,000 |
| 5 | 50 % | €120,000 | €30,000 |
| 7 | 30 % | €72,000 | €18,000 |
| 9 | 10 % | €24,000 | €6,000 |
| 10 | 0 % | €0 | €0 |
If the father dies within the first year after the gift, each child gets €60,000 extra; after 10 full years, €0. Use the mini calculator above or the compulsory share calculator for your own figures.
The spouse exception
For gifts to a spouse, the last sentence of section 2325(3) BGB says the period does not begin before the marriage is dissolved. A marriage that lasts until death means no reduction at all: €240,000 given to the wife twelve years before death counts in full, producing €60,000 per child in the example. For children from an earlier relationship this is often the decisive point. The survivor’s own position is covered under spouse’s inheritance.
Usufruct and residence rights
The statute speaks of the gift being performed. Case law reads this as requiring the donor to have actually given up enjoyment of the asset. A parent who transfers a house but keeps a comprehensive usufruct (Nießbrauch), continuing to live there or to collect the rent, has therefore usually not started the clock. Where only a right to live in some rooms was kept, courts take a more nuanced view based on how much use was reserved. Expat families who transferred German property to children while keeping it as a holiday home should not assume the 10 years are running.
Valuation and who pays
- Money and consumable items count at their value when given; other assets at their value at death, capped at the lower value at the time of the gift (section 2325(2) BGB).
- A gift the claimant received personally is added to the estate and set against their top-up (section 2327 BGB).
- Customary presents for celebrations are ignored (section 2330 BGB).
- If the heir cannot be made to pay, the recipient is liable up to the value of the gift (section 2329 BGB).
Inheritance tax has a separate, similar-looking rule: gifts from the same person are aggregated over 10 years (section 14 ErbStG), without any sliding scale. The two periods are independent of each other. The basics of the claim itself are on the compulsory share page. This explanation of the gift top-up claim is general information, not legal advice on any specific gift.